Our website uses cookies

By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

What Do Employers Look for on Background Checks? Key Hiring Considerations

Share:
A balanced scale weighs a background check report against a job role, with magnifying glass, clock, and briefcase icons representing factors employers consider when evaluating screening results

Important: The information in this article is intended for general guidance for employers and hiring professionals. It is not legal advice, and organizations should consult their legal or compliance advisors when developing hiring or background screening policies. If you are an individual looking to obtain a background check on yourself or inquire about a background report, please contact the screening provider that performed the report or the employer who requested it. Justifacts provides screening services for employers and does not process personal background check requests through this website.

What do employers look for on background checks? A finished report lists what the screening company found. Your team decides what each finding means for the hire. If that hiring decision is ever challenged, the decision is what gets reviewed.

The answer depends on the job, on the criteria you set before the report arrived, and on federal and state rules about which records you can use.

This guide is for HR, recruiting and compliance teams. It covers what employers check for, what commonly leads to a no-hire decision, how to weigh a negative finding fairly, and which records employers are restricted from using.

Quick Answer

Employers look for three things on a background check: whether the candidate's identity, work history and education match what they reported, whether any criminal record relates to the job's duties, and whether the candidate meets role requirements such as a valid license or a passing drug test. The employer's own written criteria decide which findings matter. Federal law limits what a screening company can report. Federal, state and local laws limit what an employer can use in a hiring decision.

Table of Contents

What Do Employers Look for on Background Checks?

Employers look for confirmation that a candidate's reported history is accurate, criminal history that relates to the job, and proof the candidate meets the role's specific requirements. For a full list of what a report can contain, see our guide to what background checks show.

Accurate identity, employment and education history

The report first confirms the candidate is who they say they are. Identity verification matches the candidate's name, date of birth and Social Security number to a real person. Employment verification confirms past employers, dates and job titles. Education verification confirms degrees and attendance.

Employers watch for discrepancies. An inflated job title or a degree the school never awarded says something about the candidate's honesty. A short, explainable gap between jobs usually says very little.

Criminal history related to the job

Employers weigh criminal convictions against what the job involves. A theft conviction matters for a role that handles cash or inventory. A violent offense matters for a home health aide who works alone with patients. A 15-year-old disorderly conduct misdemeanor has little bearing on most office roles.

Several related offenses over a short period usually weigh more than a single incident. Our page on criminal background checks for employment explains which county, state and federal searches feed this part of the report.

Role-specific requirements

Some jobs carry requirements that a background check confirms directly:

  • Driving roles: an MVR check shows license status and recent violations.
  • Licensed roles: professional license verification confirms that a nurse, pharmacist or contractor holds a current license in good standing.
  • Safety-sensitive roles: a pre-employment drug test shows whether the candidate meets your drug policy.
  • Financial roles: a credit check can apply to positions with access to money or sensitive financial data, in states that allow it.

Our guide to the types of background checks covers how to match these checks to each position.

Want Help Setting Screening Criteria by Role?

Tell us which positions you hire for, and we'll help you match each one to the checks and decision standards that fit its duties.

Build a Screening Package

What Fails a Background Check?

The employer's hiring criteria decide what fails a background check. The screening company reports accurate findings. The employer measures those findings against its own job-related standards. Two employers can read the same report and reach different decisions.

These findings most often lead an employer to decline a hire:

  • A conviction directly related to the job, such as a recent fraud conviction for an accounts payable role.
  • Falsified employment or education. Many employers treat a fabricated degree or job as disqualifying for any role.
  • A failed or refused drug test. For safety-sensitive and DOT-regulated positions, either one usually ends the process.
  • A disqualifying driving record for a driving role. A suspended license or a recent DUI conviction can rule a candidate out of a delivery or CDL position. Federal rules at 49 CFR 391.15 list the offenses that disqualify a commercial driver. Motor carriers are responsible for applying them.
  • A missing or invalid required license. An expired or suspended license for a role that legally requires one.

A speeding ticket that matters for a CDL driver may be irrelevant for an office manager.

How Should Employers Evaluate a Negative Finding?

Employers should weigh a negative criminal finding against three factors: the nature and severity of the offense, how much time has passed, and how closely the offense relates to the job. These factors come from Green v. Missouri Pacific Railroad (8th Cir. 1975), a federal case on race discrimination in hiring. California's Fair Chance Act uses the same three.

Weigh the offense, the time elapsed and the job

Look at how serious the offense was, how long ago it happened and when any sentence ended, then compare that to the role's actual duties. An eight-year-old embezzlement conviction carries more weight for a bookkeeper than for a warehouse associate.

Time elapsed is a judgment factor here. How far back a screening company can report is a separate rule, covered under Compliance Considerations.

Give the candidate a chance to respond

Before a final decision, give the candidate a chance to explain the finding and to dispute it. Under the FCRA, that window opens with the pre-adverse action notice, which includes a copy of the report. Compliance Considerations covers the full notice process.

The candidate can respond in two ways. The first is an explanation to your team. This step is called an individualized assessment, and the candidate may share evidence of rehabilitation, steady work since the offense, or the circumstances behind it. The second is a dispute with the screening company. If a record is inaccurate, incomplete or belongs to someone else, the candidate can dispute it, and the FCRA requires the screening company to reinvestigate, generally within 30 days (15 U.S.C. 1681i).

Several state and local laws require the individualized assessment step. California's Fair Chance Act requires employers with five or more employees to assess the conviction's relationship to the job, notify the candidate in writing, and allow at least five business days for a response (Cal. Gov. Code 12952). New York City's Fair Chance Act and New York's Correction Law Article 23-A set their own required factors.

Document the decision

Write down the criteria, the finding, the factors you weighed and the outcome. That record shows your team applied the same standard to every candidate, and counsel will ask for it first if a decision is challenged.

Which Records Are Employers Restricted From Using?

Federal, state and local laws restrict employers from using some records in hiring decisions, including arrests that did not lead to a conviction, expunged or sealed records, and in many places any criminal history before a conditional offer. Two sets of rules apply. The FCRA limits what a screening company can report. State and local laws limit what an employer can use.

Arrests without a conviction

The FCRA allows a screening company to report an arrest that did not lead to a conviction for up to seven years from the date of the arrest. Many states set a stricter rule for employers. California, New York and Illinois bar most employers from using a non-conviction arrest in a hiring decision. An arrest on its own is an unproven accusation.

Expunged, sealed and pardoned records

Once a court expunges or seals a record, a screening company should leave it off the report. The FCRA requires screening companies to follow reasonable procedures for maximum possible accuracy. Reporting a record a court has cleared can violate that standard. Many states also bar employers from considering expunged, sealed or pardoned convictions. California's law covers all three.

Criminal history before a conditional offer

Ban-the-box laws control when an employer can ask about criminal history. According to the National Employment Law Project, 37 states and more than 150 cities and counties have ban-the-box policies, and 15 states extend them to private employers. Where these laws apply, the criminal history question comes off the application, and the criminal check waits until after a conditional offer. See our guide on what employers should know about ban the box.

Credit history in states that restrict it

At least 11 states, along with Washington, D.C. and some cities, restrict credit checks for employment. Most allow them only for specific roles, such as positions with access to large sums of money. Our list of states that ban credit checks for employment has the details.

Marijuana test results in states with off-duty protections

New York, New Jersey, Minnesota and California are among the states that protect off-duty marijuana use and limit how employers can act on marijuana test results. Most of these laws carve out safety-sensitive and federally regulated roles. DOT-regulated positions still follow federal drug testing rules, which include marijuana.

Employer Considerations

A defensible screening decision starts before the report arrives, with written criteria for each role applied the same way to every candidate.

A few practices keep decisions consistent:

  • Write criteria by role before you order. Decide which findings disqualify a candidate for each position and which ones trigger a closer look.
  • Run the check after a conditional offer. This matches ban-the-box timing in most jurisdictions.
  • Train the people who read reports. Hiring managers new to screening often overreact to old or minor findings.
  • Apply the same standard to every candidate. Two candidates for the same role with similar findings should get the same outcome.

For roles where risk changes over time, such as drivers or employees with financial access, post-employment background checks keep the picture current. For the full process, see our overview of the employment background check.

Compliance Considerations

The FCRA governs how employers get and act on a background check. State and local fair chance laws add their own rules about when and how employers can use criminal history. Employers should consult legal or compliance counsel when setting screening policies.

What the FCRA requires of employers

Before ordering a background check, the employer gives the candidate a written disclosure in a standalone document and gets written authorization. If the employer may decline to hire based on the report, the FCRA sets out a two-step adverse action process.

First, the employer sends a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the CFPB's Summary of Rights. The Summary of Rights explains the candidate's right to dispute inaccurate or incomplete information with the screening company. The employer then waits a reasonable period before making a final decision.

If the candidate disputes the report, the screening company reinvestigates the disputed record. Once the dispute is resolved, the employer reviews the findings and decides whether to move forward with the hire or send the final adverse action notice. Our guide to handling adverse action walks through both notices.

What a screening company can report

Criminal convictions have no federal reporting time limit. Most other adverse records, including non-conviction arrests, motor vehicle violations and license suspensions, can be reported for seven years from the date of the record (15 U.S.C. 1681c). Bankruptcies can be reported for ten years. About a dozen states set stricter limits, including caps on how far back convictions can be reported. Our article on how far back a background check goes covers these limits.

Federal anti-discrimination law

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act prohibits employers from applying a screening policy differently based on race, national origin, sex or another protected characteristic. A policy that screens out a protected group at a higher rate, without a job-related reason, can also lead to a disparate impact claim under Title VII.

Our compliance page explains how we build FCRA requirements into every order.

Why Work with Justifacts?

Justifacts has helped employers screen candidates since 1982. We're a family-led, PBSA-accredited background screening company. We work with HR and compliance teams at organizations of every size, from local employers to companies with more than 10,000 employees, that want accurate reports and a partner who picks up the phone.

We verify records at the source, match them to the right candidate, and keep reports within federal and state limits. If a finding needs explaining, our team explains it.

  • Family-led and PBSA-accredited, screening for employers since 1982
  • Individualized assessment and adverse action support built into our platform
  • A long-tenured team serving employers of every size, including organizations with more than 10,000 employees

Key Takeaways

  • Employers look for accurate identity and work history, criminal history related to the job, and proof the candidate meets the role's requirements.
  • The employer's written, role-based criteria decide what fails a background check.
  • Employers should weigh a criminal finding by the nature of the offense, the time elapsed and its relevance to the job, then give the candidate a chance to respond.
  • Many states and cities bar employers from using non-conviction arrests, expunged or sealed records, or criminal history before a conditional offer.
  • Criminal convictions have no federal reporting time limit. Under the FCRA, most other adverse records, including arrests and motor vehicle violations, can be reported for seven years from the date of the record.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do employers look for on a background check?

Employers check that the candidate's identity, work history and education match what they reported. They also look for criminal convictions related to the job and confirm role requirements, such as a valid license or a clean driving record.

What fails a background check?

The employer's own hiring criteria decide what fails a background check. Common reasons include a job-related conviction, falsified employment or education, a failed drug test, or a missing required license.

Can employers reject candidates based on criminal history?

Yes, when the conviction relates to the job and the employer follows federal, state and local rules. Many jurisdictions require employers to wait until after a conditional offer, weigh the conviction against the job's duties, and give the candidate a chance to respond.

How do employers evaluate negative background check results?

Employers weigh the severity of the offense, how long ago it happened and how closely it relates to the job. Before a final decision, they send a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and give the candidate time to respond.

What information can employers legally consider from a background check?

Employers can generally consider job-related convictions, verified work and education history, driving records, license status and drug test results. Many states bar employers from considering arrests without a conviction or expunged and sealed records, and some restrict credit history and off-duty marijuana use.

Final Thoughts

A background check gives your team facts. Your criteria turn those facts into a hiring decision. Write role-based standards before the report arrives, weigh each finding against the actual job, and give candidates a chance to respond. Decisions made that way are easier to defend.

Our team can help you set those standards for the roles you hire for.

Talk to a Screening Specialist